In this blog post, addiction specialist Stanton Peele discusses the failure of programs like Scared Straight (where kids are exposed to hardened criminals in prison environments) to actually result in behavior modification. Again...as adults we assume that this would work - that a kid would not want that life. But, it doesn't.
It just demonstrates how important empirical data in the design of educational programs, and how lacking this is from our approach to teaching and learning.
So to look at the flip side of Scared Straight, would a program that allows rebellious children to look at the successes of a peer who decided to work hard have more impact? Like you said, it seems the Scared Straight format would be more effective. Who knows?
ReplyDeleteIt's possible...someone should try it!
ReplyDelete